Skip to content

Bag

Your bag is empty

Continue shopping

Curate your own set for up to 15% off

Get Started

Select Gifts

Tatcha Indigo Cream vs. Overnight Repair: Which Is Right For You?
Our CollectionSep 17, 2023

Tatcha Indigo Cream vs. Overnight Repair: Which Is Right For You?

Two of our most beloved formulas—the Indigo Calming Cream and the Indigo Overnight Repair—are often compared interchangeably. But they differ in a few, notable ways. Read on to discover which formula is right for your skin.

In Japan, skin is considered a conduit to the world: It perceives temperature, touch, light, and even time. It then sends those messages to the brain to distinguish how we feel and think. Our brain and skin work in tandem, which helps to synchronize our intelligent facial skin. But, this symbiotic relationship can often lead to trouble when chemical and hormonal interactions come to play, like adrenaline, inflammation, and cortisol. Pair that with external stressors like pollution, sun radiation, and poor nutrition and you might have a damaged skin barrier.

The skin barrier’s primary job is to keep moisture in and harmful substances out (including allergens, irritants, and pathogens). When it’s damaged, skin is out of sync, showing signs of dryness, redness, sensitivity, itchiness, flakiness, dullness, hyperpigmentation, and fine lines. This is where Tatcha comes into play. The Tatcha Institute has been studying and perfecting skin barrier repair for nearly a decade. Keep reading to see two products (and what makes them different) that calm and visibly relieve damaged skin.

Stressed Skin Solutions

Irritated and stressed skin can occur frustratingly easily. Thankfully there are a handful of Tatcha products that are designed to strengthen skin just as quickly. Two of our most beloved products for this very task are the Indigo Calming Cream and the Indigo Overnight Repair, but which is right for you? Read on as we uncover Tatcha Indigo Cream vs. Overnight Repair.

Indigo Calming Cream

Transform stressed skin to strengthened skin with the newly updated Indigo Calming Cream. Our beloved fragrance-free cream has been proven to calm visible irritation and relieve itchy skin, thanks to Japanese indigo and colloidal oatmeal (an FDA-designated skin protectant).

What sets this innovative cream apart from others (and even the Indigo Overnight Repair) is the addition of colloidal oatmeal, which has helped earn it the coveted National Eczema Association seal of approval for its ability to soothe irritated, eczema-prone skin on the face and beyond. Whether as a face cream or spot treatment, The Indigo Calming Cream offers a luxurious way to heal visibly stressed or eczema-prone skin for a calmer, stronger skin barrier.

100 percent of panelists in a clinical study saw an improvement in softness and suppleness immediately, an improvement in the appearance of the skin barrier after one week, and an improvement in visible redness and evenness of skin tone after four weeks. The emotional benefits of using the new Indigo Calming Cream are worth noting, too. In a clinical study self-assessment questionnaire, 86 percent of panelists noted that the product left them feeling like their skin was healthier after just one week.

Benefits:

  • Soothes dry and irritated skin
  • Relieves redness and itchiness
  • Long-lasting hydration

Texture:

  • Velvety rich cream

Use:

  • Morning and night

Ingredients:

Indigo Overnight Repair

Tatcha’s award-winning Indigo Overnight Repair is a fragrance-free, soothing serum-in-moisturizer treatment. The formula, which includes Japanese indigo, ceramides, and hyaluronic acid, provides an immediate improvement in moisture, smoothness, and radiance.

What truly sets the Overnight Repair apart from other treatments is the formula’s ability to balance the microbiome, helping to cultivate good bacteria so skin performs at its optimal, symbiotic level. The cushiony treatment is ideal for evening use, where the luxurious application can be used as an act of mindfulness and sensorial skincare moment, helping to bring comfort and peace of mind while unwinding at the end of the day. In clinical studies, 100 percent of users saw an improvement in their skin barrier strength within four weeks.

Benefits:

  • Visibly calms irritation and redness
  • Strengthens skin barrier
  • Balances skin’s microbiome

Texture:

  • A cushiony cream

Use:

  • Night only

Ingredients:

Suggested Skin-Soothing Ritual

While it’s tempting to pit Tatcha Indigo Cream vs. Overnight Repair—the two products truly work best together. Here’s our suggested daily ritual that’s proven to soothe, calm, and visibly repair skin.

Morning Ritual

  1. Purify with The Indigo Cleansing Balm
  2. Polish with The Rice Polish
  3. Plump with The Essence
  4. Nourish with The Indigo Calming Cream

Evening Ritual

  1. Purify with The Indigo Cleansing Balm
  2. Polish with The Rice Polish
  3. Plump with The Essence
  4. Nourish with The Indigo Overnight Repair

Related Products

Indigo Cleansing Balm

Gentle Moisturizing Cleanser

Sale price $38
Full size Rice Polish Calming

Foaming Enzyme Exfoliant Powder

Sale price $68
Bestseller The Essence

Healthy Aging Firming Treatment

Sale price $110
The Indigo Calming Cream

Soothing Therapeutic Moisturizer

Sale price $92

Recent Posts

View all
The Best Products to Brighten Dull Skin
Caring for SkinOct 30, 2025
The Best Products to Brighten Dull Skin

Dull skin can affect anyone, no matter your skin type or age.  To treat dullness, it’s helpful to first uncover the root cause, whether that be under-exfoliating, over-exfoliating, environmental stress, dehydration, and more.  From there, choose skin brightening products like a clever exfoliant, a multi-purpose antioxidant serum, and a reparative moisturizer, and apply them correctly An antioxidant serum, particularly one boosted with vitamin C, is the most helpful skincare product for brightening dull skin. Look for a formula that touts clinical studies, comes in airtight packaging (to ensure the formula stays potent), and doesn’t irritate your skin. 

Glutathione’s Skin Benefits: Brightening, Firming & More
Caring for SkinOct 8, 2025
Glutathione’s Skin Benefits: Brightening, Firming & More

Glutathione is a powerhouse antioxidant naturally found in the body, known for its ability to fight free radicals, brighten skin, boost collagen, and reduce inflammation.  As we age, our natural levels of glutathione decline, leading to visible signs of aging like wrinkles, loss of elasticity, and hyperpigmentation.  When applied topically, glutathione helps even skin tone, support skin firmness, and soothe inflammation, making it suitable for all skin types, including sensitive and acne-prone skin.  It pairs well with other brightening ingredients like vitamin C, enhancing their stability and effectiveness.  A high-quality glutathione serum, like The Brightening Serum, delivers both instant hydration and long-term radiance, making it a must-have for a glowing complexion.

Oil Cleanser vs. Water-Based Cleanser: Which Is Right for You?
Caring for SkinOct 8, 2025
Oil Cleanser vs. Water-Based Cleanser: Which Is Right for You?

Oil-based cleansers dissolve makeup, sunscreen, and excess oil while moisturizing the skin. Water-based cleansers remove dirt and impurities using ingredients that dissolve in water. For a deep, gentle and hydrating clean, we recommend a double-cleansing method, using an oil-based cleanser first to remove buildup, followed by a water-based cleanser for a deeper clean.  Both cleansers suit various skin types, and selecting the right cleanser depends on your skin type and needs.

View all

Subscribe to our newsletter

By signing up, you agree with our privacy policy.